Behavioural flexibility masks delayed costs of environmental instability

Environmental predictability influences the value of information acquired through experience, yet relatively little is known about how instability in resource characteristics influences behavioural organisation during foraging. We tested whether repeated changes in floral orientation, a manipulation of environmental predictability, affect pollen foraging in bumblebees (Bombus terrestris) by exposing naive workers to either stable floral conditions (single flower orientation) or repeated inter-trial changes in flower orientation (three alternating flower orientations), under constant resource availability. We quantified pollen collection, foraging efficiency, revisitation behaviour, floral coverage and sonication behaviour across three successive foraging trials of either constant or variable flower orientation, before assessing performance in a common post-treatment preference test in which bees were offered all three flower orientations and higher pollen rewards. Environmental instability altered the organisation of foraging behaviour. Bees exposed to unstable floral conditions progressively reduced flower revisitation behaviour and were less likely to perform sonication, although floral coverage, defined as the number of unique flowers visited, remained unchanged. Contrary to our predictions, instability had only weak immediate effects on pollen acquisition and foraging efficiency compared to bees tested under stable conditions. However, previous exposure to instability generated carry-over effects in the common post-treatment preference test. Bees previously exposed to unstable conditions were significantly less likely to return with pollen and consequently collected less pollen overall than bees previously exposed to stable conditions. Our results demonstrate that environmental instability can influence pollen foraging in ways that are not captured by immediate measures of performance. Although behavioural adjustments appeared to buffer short-term consequences during repeated foraging trials, carry-over effects were evident when bees were later tested in a common high-reward, multi-orientation floral array. These findings highlight the importance of considering both behavioural flexibility and carry-over effects when evaluating how organisms respond to changing environments.