A Comprehensive Benchmark of EEG-Based BCI Deep Learning Models for MCI and Dementia Classification

Electroencephalography (EEG) is a promising tool for automated detection of mild cognitive impairment (MCI) and dementia, but comparisons across studies are limited by inconsistent datasets and evaluation protocols. This study benchmarks ten deep learning models across four resting-state EEG datasets and eight binary classification tasks using a unified preprocessing pipeline and five-fold subject-wise cross-validation. Each experiment was repeated ten times. SCCNet obtained the highest mean subject-level accuracy, sensitivity, and F1 score, while ShallowConvNet achieved the highest mean segment-level accuracy, specificity, and precision. Subject-level aggregation improved mean accuracy for all evaluated models, and performance varied substantially across datasets and diagnostic tasks. Higher computational cost did not consistently correspond to better classification performance, with several compact architectures remaining competitive with substantially larger models. The results provide a reproducible reference for comparing EEG-based dementia classification models under consistent subject-independent evaluation conditions.