Genomic basis of developmental defects of enamel and sex-specific effects

We conducted a multi-ancestry genome-wide association study (GWAS) of developmental defects of enamel (DDE) in the primary dentition among 6,061 U.S. preschool-aged children (3--5 years). We investigated four DDE phenotypes (demarcated opacities, diffuse opacities, hypoplastic defects, and a combined DDE trait) leveraging main-effect models, joint gene-sex interaction testing (2df), and sex-stratified analyses. SNP-based heritability for the combined DDE trait was estimated at 20%, with concordance analyses robustly supporting a genetic etiology. We identified 39 unique genome-wide significant loci (P<5 x 10-8;), with five surpassing a study-wide Bonferroni-corrected statistical significance criterion (P<1.25 x 10-9), including Y RNA and ALDH1A1. The main-effect GWAS identified 20 loci, including HBS1L and MYB, genes regulating hematopoiesis with plausible roles in amelogenesis. Joint test and sex-stratified analyses revealed 19 additional loci, including ALDH1A1, TENM2, and DLGAP2, demonstrating sex-specific heterogeneity. Nineteen loci exhibited sex-specific differences after Bonferroni correction (P<2 x 10-3), including genes involved in retinoic acid signaling (ALDH1A1), odontogenesis (TENM2), and neurodevelopment (DLGAP2, CDH10). Pathway enrichment highlighted ectodermal and synapse organization networks, suggesting shared etiological mechanisms between DDE and systemic conditions like neurofibromatosis and autism spectrum disorder. Notably, no locus generalized in an external GWAS of permanent dentition DDE, underscoring fundamental biological differences in the genetic architectures governing primary versus permanent enamel formation. Crucially, a comprehensive cross-trait pleiotropy lookup against early childhood caries (ECC) revealed no shared genetic architecture, supporting the notion that the established clinical and epidemiological association between DDE and ECC is likely driven by structural defects increasing caries lesion susceptibility rather than genetic pleiotropy. By integrating gene-sex interaction testing, this study offers novel insights into the complex, sexually dimorphic genetic etiology of DDE and augments the biological evidence base that can support the development of precision pediatric dentistry.